PHOTOS: Dating rumors spark as Hailee Steinfeld was spotted with cheater, Josh Allen, in New York

Dating rumors spark as Hailee Steinfeld was spotted with cheater, Josh Allen, in New York.

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen and actress Hailee Steinfeld were spotted out together amid rumors that the NFL star had split from his longtime girlfriend, Brittany Williams.

While it’s unclear what might’ve caused the breakup, Allen and Williams were last seen together in March, when they took a group vacation to Mexico. The other couples on the trip included Bills backup quarterback Kyle Allen and fiancée Summer Juraszek, Jaguars wide receiver Christian Kirk and fiancée Ozzy Ozkan, along with Broncos quarterback Jarrett Stidham and his wife, Kennedy.

On Thursday, May 25, Allen was seen exiting a black SUV alongside Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse star, Hailee Steinfeld, per The New York Post. Allen was casual in a white t-shirt and jeans as he wrapped his arm around Steinfeld, 26.

Photos of Allen and Steinfeld quickly went viral as Bills Mafia processed the possible new couple. One fan tweeted, “THATS MY QUARTERBACK,” while another person wrote, “NO WAY.”

Steinfeld, PEOPLE’s latest digital star, met up with the quarterback wearing light blue jeans and a cream-colored blazer.

Allen was seen getting out of a black SUV with Steinfeld nearby, and later putting his arm on her back.

The rumors of a possible breakup came after Williams, 25, unfollowed Allen on Instagram and wiped photos of the quarterback from her account.

Neither Williams, 25, nor Allen have publicly addressed their rumored breakup, but according to the New York Post, Williams and a friend joked about “accepting husband applications” while attending the Kentucky Derby recently. 

Allen unfollowed Williams on Instagram and deleted photos of the couple on his Instagram earlier this month. The move came on the heels of both Allen and Williams attending the Kentucky Derby, although they were never photographed together.

While Allen appears to be moving on from his college sweetheart, Williams appears to be ready to do the same. On May 6, a friend of Williams, Karlee Zacky, shared a photo of the two girls at Churchill Downs on her Instagram Stories and wrote, “Now accepting husband applications @brittwilll.”